rounded corner
rounded corner
top border

Are Corn And Soybeans Bottoming?

Bookmark and Share

Are Corn And Soybeans Bottoming?

I could probably quit with a quick explanation, but some facts are needed to fully explain it. Corn and soybean futures dont need to drop much more because current cash prices and futures are bear spread.

Since farmers are storing corn, wheat and soybeans, along with other grains in larger amounts than the past few years and probably the most ever stored, now grain buyers arent worried about owning it and not being able to quickly sell or use it. Buyers and merchandisers know they wont have to cover the expenses of ownership, and futures can begin to level off. Of course, speculators may want to push down futures, but since they are already heavily short, I dont see any drastic moves to the downside. Because they are short with bear spreads, they can let the spreads slowly erode and the market will liquidate shorts as they roll to future months.

But it is sort of ironic that U.S. farmers are doing the storing. In 2015 and 2016 there were countless commentaries about Chinas stockpile of corn. Reports would talk about deterioration, sometimes rodent infestation and how difficult it was to keep corn in condition. Several times I heard farmers mocking the Chinese for doing it and even thinking deterioration would make China buy more quality corn. At least in China, the government owns the stored crops and not the farmer. And now look at China, they are using more corn ever year and now buy it at consistently lower prices. They even vanquished price supports for corn and this year havent even been taking corn from Ukraine that paid back loans from China with corn sales. Ukraine had to find other buyers. China pushed the market for a few years and now benefits from large world stocks along with their own.

I am not guessing when I know farmers are storing record bushels. The September Grain Stocks report showed higher stocks than previous years and because farmers are waiting for higher prices and for a narrower basis, they are selling what they need to pay current expenses, at least those that can pay expenses before equipment is repossessed, land is rented to another producer or the bank takes ownership.

The proof this years harvest is being stored in greater amounts can easily be seen simply by taking a drive just about any place in the Midwest.

In 2005, in a scene from the movie War of the Worlds huge tripod like machines grew out of the earth to take over the world and to harvest people. Over the past couple of weeks driving around Kansas and Missouri, I thought about the movie. Now, when the astronauts look down at farm fields in the U.S. and in some areas of Brazil, it must look like an invasion of huge white worm like creatures taking over agricultural land. As I drove around this fall, I was shocked at the number of bushels of corn and soybeans being stored in 100 yard long polyethylene bags. If I was driving in Wisconsin and corn had been grown for silage, its expected to see bags of silage, but when it is corn and even soybeans, the only conclusion that can be drawn is on-farm storage is filled to capacity and the bags are being used for storage because new crop combined with old crop remains in the bins from a year ago.

There is a belief grains should rally due to slow harvest.

If you believe it is the slow harvest, it isnt the reason. That theory is squashed with the wide basis. A wide or narrow basis is in direct relationship to how merchandisers want to buy grain and oil seeds. As far back as I can recall, I cant remember when basis has been as wide. A wide basis with low futures discourages selling.

Some reports claim movement is slow because the Mississippi River water levels are down, and barges are moving with smaller loads. Its a lot of bunk. The Army Corp of Engineers is keeping the river at current levels because of concern areas up in northern regions are too high, especially behind dams. For instance; the Mississippi River at Red Wing Lock and Dam #3 Tailwater, near the Twin Cities is at flood stage when it reaches 680.5 feet. As of November 15th, at 11:15AM central time the latest stage is 670.78 feet. If the Corp needs to release water from dam and increases flow, they adjust areas at lower levels down river. St. Louis is purposely being kept about 3 to 4 feet above levels if the Army Corp suggests to lower tonnage in barges. As of 11:15AM November 15th, the Corp has issued no advisories on the Mississippi to reduce tonnage. (Remember, the reason farmers were behind harvest in the northern Midwest. There has been too much rain and too much rain or snow in the north can be bad for areas down river along the Mississippi.

Current basis for soybeans at St. Louis River is minus 3.75 cents to minus 5.75 cents under January 2018 soybeans and corn is plus 1.50 cents to plus 3.50 cents under December 2017 corn futures. The corn and soybean basis is not bullish although there has been a narrowing.


Inspections are down from the last year (latest table below). Grain companies know from forward buy contracts what grain users in the U.S. and exporters presently want and what they will want in the months to come. Grain buyers dont want to buy grain from the farmer unless they can move it. They dont want to own it and pay even the simple carry, insurance, employees the costs to take it in and move it out of storage, hedging margins, and do the work to keep grain in condition. Merchandisers want to buy grain and move it or use it.

There has to come a time when farmers must ask themselves does storage pay? On farm storage has grown exponentially. In years past, farmers often held grain off the market at harvest and would sell into the new year because they didnt want a lot of cash in the harvest year and have to pay taxes on it. Unfortunately, with grain prices down, excess cash at harvest this year isnt the problem. It is quite the opposite. This crop year farmers are storing because they hope markets will rally. However, with world ending stocks increasing, it is difficult to see U.S. exports even coming close to the 2016/2017 crop year.

November USDA WASDE Report

Exports better increase. With extra-large ending stocks and inspections down from a year ago, they will need to increase exponentially to help prices.

Soybean ending stocks up 41.1% from a year ago and up 115.7% from 2015

Corn ending stocks up 8.3% from 2016 and up 43.1% from 2015

U.S. Grain inspections have slowed with new crop year compared to previous year

But as bad as prices may seem, as harvest comes to an end, there isnt a need to lower prices much more than they are now. Grain is stored and when buyers want it, they can narrow the basis. The futures market is giving farmers the incentive to store if they take advantage of the carry.

There are strategies for the hedger or speculator to use to take advantage of the carry with futures and/or options. Give me a call and lets talk about what strategy works with your risk exposure. I can be reached at 913.787.6804 or send me an email to and I will get back to you.

Interested in opening an account with Chris? Go to our interactive New Account application at Open An Account. It is fast, saves on postage and its green.

Futures and options trading involve significant risk of loss and may not be suitable for everyone. Therefore, carefully consider whether such trading is suitable for you in light of your financial condition. The risk of loss in trading futures and options can be substantial. Past results are not indicative of future results or performance. The views and opinions expressed in this letter are those of the author and do not reflect the views of ADM Investor Services, Inc. or its staff. Research analyst does not currently maintain positions in the commodities specified within this report. The information provided is designed to assist in your analysis and evaluation of the futures and options markets. However, any decisions you may make to buy, sell or hold a futures or options position on such research are entirely your own and not in any way deemed to be endorsed by or attributed to ADMIS. Copyright ADM Investor Services, Inc.

Recent articles from this author

About the author

For Chris Lehner's entire career, beginning in 1976 fresh out of Michigan State, he has worked with agricultural producers and businesses from the cash side of markets, to twenty-nine years as a commodities broker, branch manager, general manager and senior hedging analyst for two of the largest packing companies, livestock cooperatives, one of the largest seed companies and renowned brokerage and agricultural consulting firms.

He is a stickler about continuing education for his clients, as well as for himself.  His library has well over 100 books from the basics of fundamentals to the micro-economics of markets, technical trading and the masters of markets, plus the extensive notes and recordings from times he spent with some of the very best traders in the futures industry. 

Chris' philosophy on marketing and trading is based on the necessity to adapt to multiple variable factors, while maximizing the satisfaction of movement and change. 

Recently, a client of many years, after reading one of his marketing commentaries called him the Paul Harvey of commodities. Rather than duplicating what other analysts or reporters too often repeat, Chris tells the "rest of the story" for the bull and the bear and finishes with his own outlook.  He uses supply and demand, combined with in depth charts because, like washing hands, he personally feels using two in unison is more efficient.

Chris has a weekly news and website commentary and his daily radio grain analysis is heard in several Midwestern states. Whether it is a phone next to his ear, in person, or in front of an audience, Chris looks forward to sharing and using his experiences to enhance his clients' trading experience.
Chris can be reached at (913) 787-6804, or via email at

Published by Barchart
Home  •  Charts & Quotes  •  Commentary  •  Authors  •  Education  •  Broker Search  •  Trading Tools  •  Help  •  Contact  •  Advertise With Us  •  Commodities
Markets: Currencies  •   Energies  •   Financials  •   Grains  •   Indices  •   Meats  •   Metals  •   Softs

The information contained on is believed to be accurate but is not guaranteed. Market data is furnished on an exchange delayed basis by Data transmission or omissions shall not be made the basis for any claim, demand or cause for action. No information on the site, nor any opinion expressed, constitutes a solicitation of the purchase or sale of any futures or options contracts. is not a broker, nor does it have an affiliation with any broker.

Copyright ©2005-2018, a product. All rights reserved.

About Us  •   Sitemap  •   Terms of Use  •   Privacy Policy